Baking cookies is almost magical. You put little balls of wet, white dough into the oven and out pop brown, crispy, tasty biscuits.
“In a time-lapse video, it looks like a monster coming alive,” says the team from TEDEd in a new animation that — just in time for the holidays — explains the science behind great cookie baking. “For a moment, it [the raw dough] sits there innocuous … then it bulges outward … it triples in volume. Its color darkens ominously. And its surface hardens into an alien topography of peaks and craters. … The kitchen timer dings: Your cookies are ready.”
So what’s going on in that oven? How does the heat make our snickerdoodles and chocolate chippers so delicious?
It’s all about the chemistry.
“Don’t let that apron deceive you. Bakers are mad scientists,” the narrator of the animation says. “When you put the raw cookie dough into the oven, you’re setting off a series of chemical reactions.”
By playing around with the ingredients in your favorite recipe, you can tweak these reactions and engineer your ideal cookie. For instance, you can make it chewier, fluffy or thinner.
We’ll get to that part in a moment, but first, let’s take a look at the three major steps of the cookie-baking process:
- The spread: As the cookie dough starts to heat up, the butter inside it melts. The ball of dough loses its structural integrity and spreads out. The diameter of the cookie is set by how long the cookie expands.
- The rise: At about 212 degrees Fahrenheit, the water in the dough turns into steam. The cookie starts to rise as the vapors push through the dough. Eventually, the baking soda or powder starts to break down into carbon dioxide gas, which raise up the cookie farther. All these gases leave little holes in the maturing cookie, which makes it light and flaky.
- Color and flavor injection: Now the magic really starts to happen. Just as the cookie is almost finished baking, two chemical reactions fill it with hundreds of flavors and infuse it with its characteristic brown hue. First off, there’s caramelization: As sugars in the dough break down, they transform from clear, odorless crystals into a brown, fragrant liquid that’s overflowing with aromas and tastes — think butterscotch, sweet rum and popcorn. The second yummy process, called the Maillard reaction, packs the cookie with even richer tastes. The reaction involves not only the sugars in the dough but the proteins from the egg and flour as well. So it churns out toasty, nutty and even savory flavors. The Maillard reaction also helps to darken the cookie’s surface.
All this baking chemistry provides the building blocks for refining the cookie’s architecture, says molecular biologist Liz Roth-Johnson, who runs the Science and Food blog at the University of California, Los Angeles.
“Say I have a cookie recipe, and it’s not quite what I want,” she says. “You can take these basic concepts and use them to engineer the perfect cookie.”
Take, for instance, the cookie’s diameter. Its size depends on how quickly the dough spreads out as the butter melts in the oven.
“If you start off with melted butter in the raw dough — instead of cold butter chunks — the dough is immediately wetter and will spread out faster,” Roth-Johnson tells The Salt. The result is a flatter, wider cookie.
But the butter’s temperature will also affect the cookie’s texture. It changes the air pockets left behind as the water in the butter converts into gas, Roth-Johnson explains.
Melted butter creates smaller and more holes. That makes for a chewier cookie.
“On the other hand, if you incorporate chunks of cold butter into the dough, you get larger pockets of air and a fluffier, cakier cookie,” she explains.
You can also switch out the baking soda for baking powder for a fluffier treat. “The powder gives the cookie an extra kick of leavening,” she says, “because it produces carbon dioxide gas both when it’s mixed in the dough and when it heats up.”
To make a thicker cookie, Roth-Johnson says, try using more flour.
Finally, you can pump up the cookie’s flavor and aromas by spiking the dough with dark sugars. White granulated sugar doesn’t participate very well in the Maillard reaction because it contains mostly sucrose. Darker sugars — like molasses, honey and brown sugar — are packed with glucose and fructose, which are happy to churn out rich, complex tastes from the Maillard reaction.