Water-To-Wine Machine Sound Too Good To Be True? It Is

March 12, 2014

Think a machine that can turn water into wine is too good to be true? Well, it turns out, it is.

About two weeks ago, two wine industry gurus started marketing a home appliance they called “The Miracle Machine.” The machine, the spiel went, would use concentrates, flavor packets and “an array of electrical sensors, transducers, heaters and pumps” to make wine quickly and easily in your home.

That was enough to get 7,000 people to sign up for information about The Miracle Machine’s Kickstarter campaign. And plenty of news organizations, including ABC News and TIME, published stories about the miraculous contraption, priced at $499.

We here at The Salt are always interested in the science behind new food developments and, after consulting an oenologist, we were skeptical of how this “miracle” could be pulled off. Even if The Miracle Machine did work, just how good could its product taste? We took our doubts to a wine expert, Dr. Andrew Waterhouse, a professor of oenology at the University of California, Davis, who agreed that the whole thing sounded pretty suspect.

So we pushed and prodded and, guess what? We can now exclusively report the whole thing was a sham. Turns out, the Miracle Machine was a marketing ploy cooked up (or perhaps “fermented” would be a better word?) by MSL Group, a public relations company, to promote their pro bono client of the year, a water charity called Wine to Water.

“It was insane to see how big it got and how fast it got there,” said Philip James, one of the two wine industry figureheads behind the hoax.

James, founder of wine companies Lot18 and Snooth, teamed up with Kevin Boyer, who founded Napa Valley winery Boyanci. The two are chairman and president, respectively, of Customvine, a winemaking and marketing company. Customvine has been a supporter of Wine to Water for a while. Last year, James rode his motorcycle 17,000 miles to raise money for the charity.

“If by lending our reputations, we could bring a broader reach [to Wine to Water] and save one life, we’d do it 10 times over again,” Boyer tells The Salt.

Wine to Water claims to have provided 250,000 people in 17 countries with clean water since 2004. However, because its revenues amount to less than $1 million, it doesn’t warrant an official review or rating from watchdog sites like Charity Navigator.

Sandra Miniutti, vice president of Charity Navigator, tells us that these are some ways an individual can check out the credibility of a smaller charity:

  • Examine their financial accountability and transparency. Look for an organization’s 990 tax form, which they’re required to file, for information about financial performance and how much of the budget is spent on programs versus overhead. Miniutti says that on average, an acceptable breakdown is 75 percent programmatic spending, 25 percent overhead. (Here’s the 990 form for Water to Wine, if you want to check it out yourself.)
  • Make sure the charity has at least five independent voting members on its board of directors. This information is also available in the 990 form. “You want to make sure there’s independent oversight, not just a CEO reporting to a brother, sister and pal,” she says.
  • Make sure the charity has information readily available on its website about programs and results.
  • If it’s a local charity, pay them a visit. You can also give them a call on the phone to get a handle on whether they’re measuring and reporting results.

So the moral of this story? Always ask questions, folks. (You know, like doubting Thomas.)

Copyright 2014 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

You Care.

You are one of the CPR readers who wants to know what is really going on these days. We can help you keep up - The Lookout is a free, daily email newsletter with news and happenings from all over Colorado. Sign up here and we will see you in the morning!