Let’s start with a little word problem. Sixty percent of the nation’s 12.8 million community college students are required to take at least one course in subject X. Eighty percent of that 60 percent never move on past that requirement.
Let Y = the total percentage of community college students prevented from graduating simply by that one subject, X. What is Y?
The answer: Y = 48.
And if you haven’t guessed it by now, What is X?
The answer: Subject X equals the course sequence known as developmental or remedial math, and especially its final course, algebra.
“Here at LaGuardia, and at every community college in the country, it is the single most failed course and the gateway” that determines who graduates, says Gail Mellow, the president of LaGuardia Community College in Queens, N.Y.
Mellow is one of a growing number of educators out there who believe maybe it’s time to rethink the algebra requirement.
“More than half of the students who come to LaGuardia are not ready for college-level math,” she says. “We’re pretty typical that way. Should we take them back through high school just because math is important? Or should we take seriously the fact that these are adults, they’re overwhelmingly poor, and we want to give them the type of skills that will be useful in their lives?”
‘What Is The Purpose?’
Ashjame Pendarvis, 20, is studying in the lounge at the University of the District of Columbia Community College with her laptop, calculator and papers spread around her. She’s taking the most basic level of math at UDC.
She plans on majoring in infant and early childhood education, but she has to get two semesters of remedial math out of the way before she can start on courses relevant to her major, and two more of college-level math before she can graduate — a typical required math sequence.
“I feel like, if math isn’t important in your career then there is no need for it in college,” she says. “What’s the purpose of wasting your time and your money?”
Anyone who’s had to deal with math homework has probably heard, or uttered, a version of that complaint.
What’s surprising is that educators like Mellow agree with Pendarvis.
They’re trying a new way of teaching math that gets rid of most algebra altogether. It’s being tested on almost 5,000 students across the country. So far, many more students are succeeding in the courses, which abandon traditional math sequences in favor of new content, new teaching techniques and even a little psychology.
You Can Get It If You Really Want
“Adult learning theory tells us that adults learn better when the intellectual work is applicable to their lives,” says Mellow, who is on the steering committee of an initiative called Community College Pathways. The new approach seeks to largely skip over abstract algebraic formulas and go directly to math concepts that students will use and find engaging.
Pathways consists of a yearlong course, Statway (for “Statistics”) and a pair of semester-long courses, Quantway (for “Quantitative Reasoning”). In their traditional forms, both subjects typically come after remedial algebra in the college math sequence, and are offered for college credit.
These topics have far more immediate applications than algebraic equations do.
“Algebra is useful if you’re going to be compounding chemical substances for a manufacturing firm or if you’re an engineer,” Mellow explains. “But understanding statistics, probability, levels of risk — whether for retirement planning or the risk of your kid getting a concussion in football — those are real-life issues people will face.”
Similarly, the Quantway course is organized around concepts important for immediately useful topics: personal finance, health and civics.
This may sound like the old debate over replacing “pure math” with “applied math” or “business math.”
But Karon Klipple, who directs the Pathways project, says what’s even more important to this new approach is changing how teachers teach, and how students think about math — and even how they feel about it.
Pathways tells instructors to emphasize “productive persistence” — using good study strategies, and trying hard. They talk explicitly with students about calming math anxiety. They try things like putting students into study groups whose members are responsible for following up if one of them skips class.
And, amazingly, they’ve found that simply by teaching students that the brain is like a muscle that gets stronger with use (known as “growth mindset”), the students go on to try harder and perform better.
The Carnegie Foundation started offering Pathways in fall 2011. Currently 49 institutions use the courses, including the California State University system and community colleges in 14 states. The foundation is tracking their success closely. The institutions are all collaborating to see how they can make the courses better. (The Gates Foundation, which also supports NPR, is a supporter of this collaboration).
So far, about half of the Quantway and Statway students at LaGuardia and elsewhere finish developmental math and earn their college-level math credit within a single year.
In the traditional sequence, just 15 percent do the same — that’s in two years.
“We’ve tripled our success rate in half the time,” says Mellow.
Is This Cheating?
I ask Karon Klipple, who directs the Pathways Project, whether skipping algebra is cheating somehow.
After all, the traditional college math sequence has been in place since at least the 19th century.
Klipple says they can prove they’re not dumbing down Statway and Quantway. First of all, the material covered in the course, which does include some algebraic topics, was independently vetted by groups like the the Mathematical Association of America and the American Statistical Association. Second, a report released in July showed that Pathways students, when given the same final exam as other college-level math and statistics students, scored as well or better.
A related question is whether creating alternate pathways means tracking students — closing them off from lucrative STEM careers, for example.
“That’s what a lot of people say,” says Mellow. “I think that the way we do it now allows students to fail multiple times.”
She points out that some students who succeed in Pathways gain confidence and even a love of math, as opposed to the majority of remedial students, who retake courses again and again or drift away from college altogether.
“[Pathways] doesn’t feel like closing off anything to me. I want students to have more choices and appropriate challenges.”