PG&E Hit With $1.6 Billion Penalty For 2010 Calif. Pipeline Explosion

April 9, 2015

Pacific Gas & Electric Co.has been ordered to pay a $1.6 billion penalty – the largest ever levied against a public utility – for a 2010 explosion in a gas pipeline it operated that killed eight people and destroyed dozens of homes in a San Francisco suburb.

The five-member California Public Utilities Commission voted 4-0 Thursday, with the commission president, Michael Picker, abstaining, to impose the penalty. Picker, however, called for a larger review of problems at PG&E, a move that The Associated Press says “suggests the energy behemoth could be broken up.”

The AP writes:

“Picker said state safety citations against PG&E were rising, but that the utility was so big, with $1.6 billion in earnings in 2014, that it was able to shrug off financial penalties. …

‘The commission will study ‘the culture of safety’ and organizational structure of Pacific Gas & Electric Co., which has its gas and electricity operations under a single corporate board and chief executive.”

The Los Angeles Times says of the explosion five years ago in San Bruno that 58 people were injured and 38 homes destroyed.

According to the Times:

“The PUC action, which had been more than four years in the making, requires PG&E to pay $850 million for improvements to its natural gas pipeline system.

“Another $300 million will go to the state’s general treasury, $400 million will be refunded to PG&E gas customers as a one-time credit and $50 million will pay for a variety of safety activities by PUC staff and contractors.

“The entire $1.6 billion fine would be paid for by the company and shareholders — not by ratepayers.”

Copyright 2015 NPR. To see more, visit