Previously, on Serial …
“All this time I thought the courts proved it was Adnan that killed her. I thought he was where he deserved to be. Now I’m not so sure.”
That’s an email from Asia McLean to host Sarah Koenig, as read on the very first episode of Serial, the podcast sensation produced by the creators of This American Life.
Today McLean was in court, giving testimony that could convince a judge to order a new trial for Syed. Andrea Seabrook was in the courtroom, reporting for NPR.
“Today the judge heard testimony from Asia McLean. Serial listeners will probably remember that name,” Seabrook said on All Things Considered. “She is the one who says she saw Adnan Syed in the library at the exact same time that the state said he was out committing a murder.”
Seabrook reports that McLean brought notes and cell phone data that contradict what prosecutors have said in past proceedings.
“What’s fascinating about her is she didn’t even know how important she was to the case until she heard about it on Serial,” Seabrook says.
Many of the people in the courtroom were Serial podcast listeners, Seabrook said, adding that members of Syed’s family were also present. After the day’s hearing concluded, the family of Hae Min Lee, who Syed was convicted of murdering in 1999 released the following statement:
“Our family has lived without a heart for over 17 years. And we continue to grieve every day in private.
“The immediate family members have decided not to attend this hearing. But we are grateful to all the people who are there and will be there to support us and to give Hae a voice. She is the true victim.
“Although this has made us relive a nightmare we thought was behind us, we thank the State for standing up for us and continuing to seek justice. We believe justice was done when Adnan was convicted in 2000, and we look forward to bringing this chapter to an end so we can celebrate the memory of Hae instead of celebrating the man who killed her.
“We ask that you keep Hae in your thoughts and prayers.”
The judge will hear testimony Thursday and Friday, but it is unclear when he will make a decision.
Our original post continues:
If you’re just catching up, each season of Serial follows a single true story, told episode by episode.
The first season investigated the case of Adnan Syed, who was convicted of murdering his girlfriend more than 15 years ago. Host Sarah Koenig and her team uncovered inconsistencies in his case — including the fact that Asia McLean was an alibi witness. She said she’d seen Syed at the time Hae Min Lee’s murder occurred, but that testimony was never brought forth in court.
Now Syed is back in court — at a hearing that offers a chance at a second trial.
As Seabrook reported on Morning Edition, it’s a surprising development for a case like this.
“Syed was convicted. He’s been in prison for more than 15 years — he’s 35 now,” she says. “It’s remarkable that he is getting a hearing now.”
He was convicted in 2000 of the murder of Hae Min Lee in 1999.
Syed’s new defense attorney, C. Justin Brown, says he’ll be presenting witnesses and exhibits, Seabrook reports. “We’re confident that after we have entered all the evidence that the judge is going to carefully consider it and it’s going to win Adnan Syed a new trial,” Brown says.
As Seabrook notes, there’s no guarantee of redemption here. Even Koenig, after researching Syed’s case for a year, wasn’t entirely convinced he was innocent.
But she did conclude, as she said on All Things Considered, that “something went wrong with this case.”
It’s not the first time Syed has requested a new trial. The Baltimore Sun reports that his most recent attempt, in 2012, was denied “in a sparsely attended hearing.”