North Korea announced Tuesday that Malaysian citizens in the country would not be allowed to leave, and Malaysia retaliated by broadening a previous travel ban on North Korean Embassy officials to cover all North Korean citizens in the country.
So, more than three weeks after the half-brother of North Korea’s leader was murdered in a Kuala Lumpur airport terminal, the two countries are in a full-blown diplomatic standoff.
“Malaysia, which was once one of the few countries friendly with North Korea, has had a significant falling out with the hermit kingdom over the death of Kim Jong Nam. Malaysian authorities say Kim was killed with VX nerve agent, a banned chemical weapon, and they have arrested two women who appeared to accost him in the airport’s surveillance footage.
“Pyongyang, for its part, disputes this account, saying the man — whom North Korea has not officially recognized as Kim Jong Nam — ‘probably died of a heart attack because he suffered from heart disease, diabetes and high blood pressure.’
“The U.S. and South Korean officials attribute Kim’s death to North Korean agents.”
Following Tuesday’s announcement that all Malaysian citizens would be barred from leaving North Korea, Malaysian Prime Minister Najib Razak accused the North Korean government of “effectively holding our citizens hostage,” The Guardian reported.
Malaysia has an embassy in Pyongyang. “Malaysia’s foreign ministry said it had 11 citizens in North Korea, including three embassy staff, six family members and two others,” reported the newspaper. “Neither country has announced how many North Koreans live in Malaysia.”
The Associated Press estimated about 1,000 North Koreans in Malaysia were affected by the exit ban.
The Guardian also quoted Malaysia’s chief of police as saying that three North Korean nationals wanted in connection with the killing were hiding in the country’s embassy in Kuala Lumpur as of Tuesday, and that a North Korean diplomat was among those wanted for questioning in connection with the murder.
The two countries already kicked out each other’s ambassadors over the murder — Malaysia first, on Saturday, and then North Korea on Monday, according to The Associated Press (although the Malaysian government had beaten Pyongyang to the punch by recalling their top diplomat back on Feb. 20).
That process, in which each country declared the other’s top diplomat persona non grata, is in keeping with the 1961 Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, to which both countries are signatories.
However, the new exit bans and criminal investigation involving diplomats are more murky in their legality under the treaty, which guarantees diplomatic immunity from criminal prosecution.
Only the sending state can revoke that immunity.
The U.N. convention also states that “the receiving State shall ensure to all members of the mission freedom of movement and travel in its territory,” and says specifically that:
“The receiving State must, even in case of armed conflict, grant facilities in order to enable [diplomats] … to leave at the earliest possible moment. It must, in particular, in case of need, place at their disposal the necessary means of transport for themselves and their property.”
Don Rothwell, professor of international law at the Australian National University, told Reuters that he believed the exit ban for Malaysian Embassy staff and their families in Pyongyang was a clear violation of the convention.
The U.N. Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which Malaysia has signed, also explicitly establishes the right of every person “to leave any country.”