President Trump sent Congress, on Sunday, a list of sweeping immigration changes he says “must be included as part of any legislation addressing the status of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) recipients.”
Trump wants the border wall he campaigned on to be built, a crackdown on illegal immigration and to switch the U.S. legal immigration system from one that prioritizes family connections to one based on merit.
Trump has promoted these policies before, both during the campaign and as president. But what’s new is demanding that they be included in the legislative fix for the DACA program.
“Without these reforms, illegal immigration and chain migration, which severely and unfairly burden American workers and taxpayers, will continue without end,” Trump said in a letter to Congress.
Last month, concluding that the DACA program put into place by the Obama administration through executive action was illegal, Trump announced that he would end it in six months, and called on Congress to enshrine in law the protections for undocumented immigrants who were brought to the country as children. The approximately 700,000 DACA recipients are often referred to as “Dreamers.” Under the program, they temporarily avoid deportation and receive work permits.
Around that time, Trump had dinner at the White House with the two top congressional Democrats, House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi and Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, and all emerged talking about the rough outlines of a deal. A major component of that agreement was President Trump’s willingness to take funding the border wall off the table, when it came to DACA legislation.
After the apparent agreement with Pelosi and Schumer, conservatives vocalized their rage, accusing Trump of abandoning the hard-line immigration platform he campaigned on, as NPR noted. Conservative commentator Ann Coulter said at the time, “If we’re not getting a wall, I’d prefer President Pence,” she added.
“DACA now, and the wall very soon,” Trump told reporters on the south lawn of the White House in mid-September. “But the wall will happen.”
The White House immigration principles appear to be a departure from that earlier statement. White House documents call for “completing construction of a wall along the southern border of the United States” and ensuring “funding for the southern border wall and associated infrastructure.”
Pelosi and Schumer say these proposals are a clear break with what they believe was agreed to during that dinner at the White House.
“We told the President at our meeting that we were open to reasonable border security measures alongside the DREAM Act, but this list goes so far beyond what is reasonable,” Pelosi and Schumer said in a statement. This proposal fails to represent any attempt at compromise.”
Beyond the wall, the Democrats say the administration’s list is “anathema to the Dreamers, to the immigrant community and to the vast majority of Americans.”
Although Republicans control both chambers of Congress, they have a narrow majority in the Senate and have struggled to pass even top legislative prioritie. And it’s not clear that all, or even most, Republicans back what President Trump is proposing on immigration. Passing a DACA fix is a top priority for Democrats, but they won’t go along with Trump’s long list of demands, meaning what once seemed like a bipartisan compromise in the works now looks more like another legislative standoff.
In his letter to Congress, President Trump said the list of proposals was developed from the bottom up, working with law enforcement professionals on the front lines of America’s immigration system.
“In response, they identified dangerous loopholes, outdated laws, and easily exploited vulnerabilities in our immigration system — current policies that are harming our country and our communities,” said Trump’s letter to Congress.
These recommendations happen to also align nicely with Trump’s campaign rhetoric.
Among the recommendations, as described by the White House:
- Fund and complete construction of the southern border wall
- Ensure the safe and expeditious return of Unaccompanied Alien Children (UAC) and family units
- End abuse of our asylum system by tightening standards, imposing penalties for fraud, and ensuring detention while claims are verified
- Remove illegal border crossers quickly by hiring an additional 370 immigration judges and 1,000 ICE attorneys
- Stop “sanctuary cities”
- Strengthen law enforcement by hiring 10,000 more ICE officers and 300 federal prosecutors
- End visa overstays by establishing reforms to ensure their swift removal.
- Protect U.S. workers by requiring E-Verify and strengthening laws to stop employment discrimination against U.S. workers
- End extended-family chain migration by limiting family-based green cards to include spouses and minor children
- Establish a points-based system for green cards to protect U.S. workers and taxpayers
Senator Tom Cotton, R-Ark., quickly offered praise.
“The principles the president has put out show he understands what’s broken in our immigration system and what’s holding down wages for American workers,” Cotton said in a statement. “I’m especially glad to see him call for ending chain migration and moving to a skills-based immigration system. These kinds of reforms are long overdue.”
Cotton introduced a bill to create a skills-based immigration system earlier this year, and while President Trump voiced support for it at a White House event, the bill has just one co-sponsor.