New Memorial To Native Veterans Celebrates A Complicated Legacy Of Service

Listen Now
3min 47sec
Alan Karchmer / National Native American Veterans Memorial
Photo by Alan Karchmer for NMAI
The National Native American Veterans Memorial was designed by Harvey Pratt, the same artist who is creating the Sand Creek memorial at Colorado’s state capitol.

The National Mall is generally quiet these days, as the resurgent COVID-19 pandemic keeps people home and the museums of the Smithsonian shuttered.

Those who do venture to its quiet paths will find something new — the National Native American Veterans Memorial. The memorial, found on the grounds of the National Museum of the American Indian, opened on Veterans Day 2020 with a virtual ceremony.

Former Colorado Sen. Ben Nighthorse Campbell, a member of the Northern Cheyenne, was instrumental in the museum’s creation; the bill to authorize it was among the first he passed in Congress and its opening, 18 years later in 2004, came just months before he retired from the Senate.

“I join my Native brothers and sisters in our love for our country, and our willingness to don the uniform of the United States to defend her when our nation needs us most,” Campbell, a Korean War veteran, said in a video the museum produced to mark the new memorial’s virtual unveiling. “I take great pride in my service to our nation, and the service of our Native American people throughout the nation.”

The heart of the leafy memorial is a tall silver ring. Water flows around its base and the surrounding plaza is ringed by sculpted lances where people can attach prayer flags, as well as benches to sit and contemplate.

Alan Karchmer / National Native American Veterans Memorial
Photo by Alan Karchmer for NMAI
"People that come here, they're going to be blessed and healed and they will think about their family, and the family will think about the veterans and this will become a place of power," artist Harvey Pratt said of his memorial, 'Warriors' Circle of Honor.'

The memorial, titled ‘Warriors’ Circle of Honor,’ was designed by the Cheyenne and Arapaho artist Harvey Pratt, who is also creating the Sand Creek memorial that will go on the grounds of the Colorado state capitol.

“Over and over, veterans said they wanted a place to heal. Remember yes, that’s what a memorial is, but also a place for healing,” said Alexandra Harris, the museum’s senior editor and writer.

Harris recently authored a book and an exhibition about Native veterans and their reasons for serving.

It’s widely repeated that Native Americans serve in the military at a higher rate than any other ethnic group. But that, according to Harris, is actually a long-running bit of government propaganda. She traced it back to World War I and the Commissioner of Indian Affairs, Cato Sells, who used the phrase in his efforts to get more Native Americans to enlist.

“He was a staunch assimilationist,” Harris said. “He believed that American Indians should give up their culture and land. And he saw the war as an avenue to do so.”

That said, Native Americans do join the military at a high rate, and have fought in every U.S. conflict going back to the Revolutionary War. However, given the military’s role in the displacement and subjugation of Indigenous people throughout the course of the nation’s history, the idea that many Native Americans see themselves as part of a tradition of military service may seem a bit contradictory to non-natives.

“How do you square that tradition with what you understand about Native American history and America's relationship, the nation's relationship with native people?” said Historian Mark Hirsch, Harris’s coauthor.

It’s a question their book, “Why We Serve,” tries to answer.

Many of the reasons have a universal ring: people come from military families, or they were drafted, or looking for a new opportunity and a way out of a bad situation. For many, it's the opportunity to defend the homeland they've inhabited for millennia.  

Jeffrey Means signed up with the Marines as a young man because he lacked other opportunities after high school. He’s a member of the Oglala Sioux nation and found the Marine Corps was welcoming if less than politically correct.

“I had a fellow Marine who looked a whole lot more Native American than I do, and of course his nickname was Chief,” he recalled. 

Means’ response was to give as good as he got. He laughs remembering, “I used to joke with all my white friends and say, ‘you better watch it. Me and Steve will pull up a Little Big Horn on your asses’ … To let them know that we weren't gonna take any guff.”

Means, who is now a history professor at the University of Wyoming, speaks fondly of his time in the Marines, but doesn’t downplay the military’s role in displacing native tribes throughout the nation’s history.

“The United States military has done many wonderful and honorable things. We don't need to pretend that the United States Army never did anything bad. It's just, it's just not factual,” he said.

Means notes that even during westward expansion, the military’s relationship with Native tribes was often contradictory. U.S. troops committed numerous massacres and atrocities. But individual soldiers were often more familiar with Native Americans than civilian settlers were.

“So they were generally treated better by U.S. soldiers and more reasonably because they didn't have that mass hysteria of, ‘Oh my gosh, the Savage is going to come kill us.’” 

The military’s infamous legacy with tribes continues to linger. The massacre at Wounded Knee resulted in 20 Medals of Honor and congressional efforts to rescind them have so far stalled. The CIA’s codename for Osama Bin Laden was “Geronimo,” after the Apache chief. Today, some military commanders continue to refer to hostile territory overseas as “Indian Country.” 

The campaign website for President-Elect Joe Biden addresses those issues, declaring in the Tribal Nations section that his administration will “Demonstrate respect for Native communities by changing military naming conventions that label enemy-held territory as “Indian Country” and codenames enemy combatants after historic indigenous and tribal figures.” 

“I think America, as a country, hasn't really grappled with its history with Native people. So, from the top down, we can't infuse our institutions in this country with that level of reconciliation that we need to do with Native people [until the nation can address that history and see them as individuals and not stereotypes],” said the Smithsonian’s Harris.

With the consecration of the National Native American veterans’ memorial, the country now has a place to remember the service of native people on behalf of the United States, even though the nation has not always served them well.

Editor's Note: This story has been updated to clarify the intention of Alexandra Harris' final quote.

This story was produced by the American Homefront Project, a public media collaboration that reports on American military life and veterans. Funding comes from the Corporation for Public Broadcasting.